"This is for our youth," Islamorada Mayor Don Horton said at the Oct. 1 groundbreaking for the Founders Park baseball field, as Keys Weekly reported. It rained that morning and the ground was muddy, but the ceremony still ended years of back-and-forth between the Village of Islamorada and the Monroe County School District over a $3.8 million project.
The mayor's line explains more than the ball field. In 2026, the money spent at Founders Park has gone into the surfaces people swim and play on. The parts built for people who come to watch are mostly still waiting. If you live on Plantation Key and use the park, it is in better shape this fall than it has been for a while. If you go to sit, cheer or browse, the place to be is the Great Lawn, and the lawn has two big nights coming up.
The ball field is getting the turf. The grandstand waits.
The field at 87000 Overseas Highway is owned by the village, and for decades the Coral Shores High School baseball program has practiced and played there under an agreement with the school district. The proposed upgrades reopened that agreement. The two governing bodies held a rare joint meeting, settled who controls what and who pays for what, and agreed to a 20-year pact in late July. In Keys Weekly's account of that July 21 meeting, the village owns the property and the school board is paying about $3.8 million for the improvements. School board member Sue Woltanski explained at that meeting that adding bleachers complicates the project, because building codes tie bleachers of certain sizes to bathrooms of a specific capacity.
The case for turf came from the field itself. Keys Weekly reported that Keys weather made it hard to keep the natural grass playable year-round, and that the program and its coaches pushed for a safer surface after Coral Shores players were hurt on it in recent seasons. At a July 2025 meeting, Islamorada Parks & Recreation committee member Jon Weare, a retired pediatrician, said turf raises concerns for soccer, lacrosse and field hockey because of their sudden movements, but called artificial turf a safe surface for baseball.
What gets built this round shows the priority clearly. The original plan was $6 million. The approved project is $3.8 million, and Keystar is building it.
| Part of the plan | Status as of the Oct. 1 groundbreaking |
|---|---|
| Artificial turf playing surface | Under construction |
| New fencing | Under construction |
| Dugouts | Under construction |
| Batting cages | Under construction |
| Bleachers | Set aside for future discussion |
| Two-story building with concession stand, bathrooms and press box | Set aside for future discussion |
The target is to have the improvements ready when players take the field for the upcoming season. Families who go to games should expect a much better field and the same spectator setup for now. No restroom or concession building is planned for the near term. Bleachers and the press box are waiting on a future decision with no date set.
The pool already got the same treatment
The Ron Levy Aquatic Center had its overhaul first, and the work followed the same pattern. The pool closed on Feb. 1, 2026, for resurfacing and facility work, and reopened on June 18. According to Keys Weekly's reopening coverage, the project covered the interior surface, the mechanical systems, lighting, railings, the scoreboard and the locker rooms. It also added a first-aid office and break room for the lifeguards.
Most of that list sits below the waterline or behind the locker room doors, where swimmers and staff feel it every day. The scoreboard is the one item built for people watching from the deck.
For Islamorada residents, using all of it is cheap. The village fee schedule effective March 1, 2026, lists Founders Park entry as free for Islamorada residents. Daily pool admission is $3 for youth and seniors and $5 for adults.
When guests come along
The same fee schedule matters when friends or family visit. Nonresidents can buy one-month memberships that include park entry:
- Youth and seniors: $30 for park only, $60 for park and pool
- Adults: $45 for park only, $90 for park and pool
- Families of up to four: $125 for park only, $175 for park and pool
The schedule says a membership covers only the named cardholders, guests pay the entrance fee, and extra per-person park charges apply in summer and on specified holiday weekends. If relatives are staying through a holiday, check the current schedule before you drive them over.
Where the crowds go instead: the Great Lawn
Founders Park covers 45 acres, with a shallow-water beach, an Olympic-size pool, a splash pad, sports courts, playgrounds, a dog park and a marina. On its two biggest nights this season, the gathering happens on none of those. It happens on the Great Lawn, well away from the construction at the ball field.
- 8th Annual Trunk or Treat, Saturday, Oct. 24, 6 to 8:30 p.m. The village lines the Great Lawn with decorated car trunks handing out candy. Around them are an inflatable obstacle course, a bounce house, a pumpkin decorating station, a DJ, juggling and face painting. The night builds to a costume parade and contest. Food and soft drinks are for sale on site, parking is $15, and trunk registration is open to anyone who wants to decorate a car and hand out candy, according to the Florida Keys tourism council's event listing.
- 22nd Annual Islamorada Holiday Fest, Friday, Dec. 4, 4 to 10 p.m. The Islamorada Chamber of Commerce is again hosting it on the Great Lawn. The program includes Snow Mountain, a holiday bazaar with local vendors, Santa activities, live stage performances and the Santa Paws Pet Parade. The parade starts at 7:30 p.m.
Trunk or Treat is this Saturday, so anyone thinking about decorating a trunk should register soon.
A new name at the park entrance
The Chamber's visitor center sits at the Founders Park entrance, 87100 Overseas Highway, and the Chamber is changing leaders just ahead of its biggest event. Keys Weekly reported on Oct. 5 that the Islamorada Chamber had named Katie Brennan executive director. She was expected to start in mid-October, succeeding Judy Hull, who is retiring. That puts Holiday Fest among the first big events of Brennan's tenure.
One Sunday errand that isn't at Founders
The Florida Keys Farmers Market is held every Sunday from 10 a.m. to 3 p.m. at Islamorada Gardens Plaza, 81001 Overseas Highway, a few miles down the road from the park. It is listed on the Florida Keys tourism council's events page.
What the next few months look like at the park
The season breaks down into three things. The pool reopened in June after its rebuild. The ball field is under construction with a target of the coming baseball season. The Great Lawn hosts Trunk or Treat on Oct. 24 and Holiday Fest on Dec. 4. The bleachers and the concession, restroom and press-box building are next in line for discussion, and no timeline has been set.
For more on this stretch of the islands, see our guide to Islamorada and the Upper Keys, or read our fall update on what's open at Pennekamp a short drive north.
Our Islamorada office works in the Upper Keys every day, and we follow projects like the Founders Park field because they shape everyday life on Plantation Key. If you'd like to talk about the village, its parks or your own plans in the area, BHHS Knight & Gardner Realty would be glad to hear from you. Contact Us.