Leave a Message

Thank you for your message. We will be in touch with you shortly.

819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
SEE ALL PHOTOS
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
819 Simonton Street
Sold

819 Simonton Street

819 Simonton Street, Key West, FL 33040

$12,500,000
The Paradise Inn, with its subtle luxury and Bahamian charm, is situated in the center of
Old Town Key West only a short walk or bicycle ride from the shops at Mallory Square, Duval Street, The Ernest Hemingway Home, and The Key West Butterfly Conservatory. The Hotel features an upscale amenity base including spacious gardens filled with exotic flora, a fountain-fed pool, jacuzzi, complimentary breakfast, daily wine & cheese happy hour, and 24-hour coffee. Ownership also owns a two-story building next to Paradise, on 817 Simonton Street, where there is a fully renovated 2BR/1BA apartment, with private balcony, and washer and dryer on the second floor. On the first floor there
is a commercial space that is currently leased out as a SPA. There are also six parking spaces at this Property.

10,305 Sq.Ft. LIVING AREA

0.78 Acres lot

Team Gardner/Langley

Team Gardner/Langley

Features & Amenities

Area & Lot

  • Status Sold
  • Date Sold July 23, 2025
  • Living Area10,305 Sq.Ft.
  • Total Area10,305 Sq.Ft.
  • Lot Area0.78 Acres
  • MLS® ID611314
  • TypeCommercial
  • YEAR BUILT1995
  • NeighborhoodOld Town Key West
  • View DescriptionNo Waterview

Exterior

  • STORIES2

Financial

  • Sales Price$12,500,000
  • Real Estate Tax $63,609/yr
  • Zoning HRCC - Historic Residential Commercial Core

Old Town Key West

Explore

Work With Us

Whether you're buying or selling in the Florida Keys, get expert guidance, local insight, and a smooth experience from start to finish.

Follow Us on Instagram